NY-20 2009

A special election (by-election, if thee prefers) was held in New York’s 20th congressional district last night. The by-election was snapped by the appointment by New York Governor David Paterson (D) of NY-20 Representative Kirsten Gillibrand (D) to the Senate seat vacated by the now-SoS Hillary Clinton (D). Gillibrand, a Blue Dog Dem (conservative Democrat) defeated Republican incumbent John Sweeny in a traditionally conservative and Republican district. However, NY-20 has been trending Democratic over the past few cycles. First, with Gillibrand’s 2006 election and huge re-election in 2008, but also with Obama’s victory in the district with 51% (54-46 for Bush in 2004).

NY-20 starts outside of Poughkeepsie and goes up all the way to Lake George/Mount Placid and the scenic Adirondacks in northern New York. NY-20 includes most of the residential Hudson River Valley, the Republican-leaning suburbia of Albany-Schenectady-Troy, Saratoga Springs, and rural areas in Greene, Delaware, and Ostego Counties. Here is a map of the district. As expected, NY-20 is whiteland, 93% white and 3.7% foreign born. Median HH income is $54,941, slightly above average. Few renters, largely white-collar but there is an important labour demographic.

The candidates in this election were Jim Tedisco, the Republican minority leader in the state Assembly who represents AD 110 (including Saratoga County) and Scott Murphy, a Democratic businessman. Eric Sundwall, a Libertarian, attempted to run, but failed to do so, citing, ironically “Stalinist election laws”. Tedisco had a bit of a shaky campaign, to say the least, and his significant poll lead turned into a narrow poll deficit in the last week. Noteworthy to note that Tedisco does not live in NY-20, but in NY-21.

With all 610 precincts reporting, but no absentee votes in yet, these be the results. It’s very close.

New York-20 (PVI R +3, 2004)
Scott Murphy (D) 77,217 / 50.01% (+25 votes)
Jim Tedisco (R) 77,192 / 49.99%

This race could last up to April 13, maybe even longer, depending on absentee ballots from out of the districts and abroad. It’s impossible to say how these will break. Military and senior absentees are Republican, but there could be a lot of ballots from uni students studying NYC but who live in the district, and those are Democrat. So, it’s hard to say. Quasi-impossible.

Another fun recount!

Anyways, here is a map of the district, done by rough 10% intervals and margin.


Compared to 2006 (53-47 D), Murphy did better than Gillibrand in Delaware (+3.74%), Essex (+1.75%), Warren (+1.92%), and Washington (+2.88%). The Democrats lost the most votes in Saratoga (-6.5%). Part of Saratoga is in Tedisco’s AD.

Posted on April 2, 2009, in By-elections, New York, U.S.A.. Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: